Solution Manual for Financial Statement Analysis and Valuation 2nd Edition by Easton

Instant download Solution Manual for Financial Statement Analysis and Valuation 2nd Edition by Easton pdf docx epub after payment.

 

Module 1

 

Framework for Analysis and Valuation

 

QUESTIONS

Q1-1.   Organizations undertake planning activities that shape three major activities: financing, investing, and operating. Financing is the means a company uses to pay for resources. Investing refers to the buying and selling of resources necessary to carry out the organization’s plans. Operating activities are the actual carrying out of these plans. Planning is the glue that connects these activities, including the organization’s ideas, goals and strategies. Financial accounting information provides valuable input into the planning process, and, subsequently, reports on the results of plans so that corrective action can be taken, if necessary.

Q1-2.   An organization’s financing activities (liabilities and equity = sources of funds) pay for investing activities (assets = uses of funds). An organization’s assets cannot be more or less than its liabilities and equity combined. This means: assets = liabilities + equity. This relation is called the accounting equation (sometimes called the balance sheet equation), and it applies to all organizations at all times.

Q1-3.   The four main financial statements are: income statement, balance sheet, statement of stockholders’ equity, and statement of cash flows. The income statement provides information about the company’s revenues, expenses and profitability over a period of time. The balance sheet lists the company’s assets (what it owns), liabilities (what it owes), and stockholders’ equity (the residual claims of its owners) as of a point in time. The statement of stockholders’ equity reports on the changes to each stockholders’ equity account during the year. The statement of cash flows identifies the sources (inflows) and uses (outflows) of cash, that is, where the company got its cash from and what it did with it. Together, the four statements provide a complete picture of the financial condition of the company.

Q1-4.   The balance sheet provides information that helps users understand a company’s resources (assets) and claims to those resources (liabilities and stockholders’ equity) as of a given point in time. 

Q1-5.   The income statement covers a period of time. An income statement reports whether the business has earned a net income (also called profit or earnings) or incurred a net loss.  Importantly, the income statement lists the types and amounts of revenues and expenses making up net income or net loss.

 

 

Q1-6.     The statement of cash flows reports on the cash inflows and outflows relating to a company’s operating, investing, and financing activities over a period of time. The sum of these three activities yields the net change in cash for the period. This statement is a useful complement to the income statement, which reports on revenues and expenses, but which conveys relatively little information about cash flows.

Q1-7.     Retained earnings (reported on the balance sheet) is increased each period by any net income earned during the period (as reported in the income statement) and decreased each period by the payment of dividends (as reported in the statement of cash flows and the statement of stockholders’ equity).  Transactions reflected on the statement of cash flows link the previous period’s balance sheet to the current period’s balance sheet. The ending cash balance appears on both the balance sheet and the statement of cash flows.

Q1-8.     External users and their uses of accounting information include: (a) lenders for measuring the risk and return of loans; (b) shareholders for assessing the return and risk in acquiring shares; and (c) analysts for assessing investment potential. Other users are auditors, consultants, officers, directors for overseeing management, employees for judging employment opportunities, regulators, unions, suppliers, and appraisers.

Q1-9.     Managers deal with a variety of information about their employers and customers that is not generally available to the public. Ethical issues arise concerning the possibility that managers might personally benefit by using confidential information. There is also the possibility that their employers and/or customers might be harmed if certain information is not kept confidential.

Q1-10.^A Procter & Gamble’s independent auditor is Deloitte & Touche LLP. The auditor expressly states that “our responsibility is to express an opinion on these financial statements based on our audits.” The auditor also states that “these financial statements are the responsibility of the company’s management.” Thus, the auditor does not assume responsibility for the financial statements.

Q1-11.^B While firms acknowledge the increasing need for more complete disclosure of financial and nonfinancial information, they have resisted these demands to protect their competitive position. Corporate executives must weigh the benefits they receive from the financial markets as a result of more transparent and revealing financial reporting against the costs of divulging proprietary information to competitors and others.

Q1-12.^B Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) are the various methods, rules, practices, and other procedures that have evolved over time in response to the need to regulate the preparation of financial statements.  They are primarily set by the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB), a private sector entity with representatives from companies that issue financial statements, accounting firms that audit those statements, and users of financial information. Other bodies that contribute to GAAP are the AICPA, the EITF, and the SEC.

 

Q1-13.^B Corporate governance is the system of policies, procedures and mechanisms that protect the interests of stakeholders in the business. These stakeholders include investors, creditors, regulatory bodies, and employees, to name a few. Sound corporate governance involves the maintenance of an effective internal auditing function, an independent and effective external auditing function, an informed and impartial board of directors, governmental oversight (such as from the SEC), and the oversight of the courts.

Q1-14.^B The auditor’s primary function is to express an opinion as to whether the financial statements fairly present the financial condition of the company and are free from material misstatements. Auditors do not prepare the financial statements; they only audit them and issue their opinion on them.  The auditors provide no guarantees about the financial statements or about the company’s continued performance.

Q1-15.  Financial accounting information is frequently used in order to evaluate management performance. The return on equity (ROE) and return on net operating assets (RNOA) provide useful measures of financial performance as they combine elements from both the income statement and the balance sheet. Financial accounting information is also frequently used to monitor compliance with external contract terms. Banks often set limits on such items as the amount of total liabilities in relation to stockholders’ equity or the amount of dividends that a company may pay. Audited financial statements provide information that can be used to monitor compliance with these limits (often called covenants). Regulators and taxing authorities also utilize financial information to monitor items of interest.

Q1-16. Managers are vitally concerned about disclosing proprietary information that might benefit the company’s competitors. Of most concern, is the “cost” of losing some competitive advantage. There has traditionally been tension between companies and the financial professionals (especially investment analysts) who press firms for more and more financial and nonfinancial information.

Q1-17.  Net income is an important measure of financial performance. It indicates that the market values the company’s products or services, that is, it is willing to pay a price for the products or services enough to cover the costs to bring them to market and to provide the company’s investors with a profit. Net income does not tell the whole story, however. A company can always increase its net income with additional investment in something as simple as a bank savings account. A more meaningful measure of financial performance comes from measuring the level of net income relative to the investment made. One investment measure is the balance of stockholders’ equity, and the comparison of net income to average stockholders’ equity (ROE) is a fundamental measure of financial performance.

Q1-18.  Borrowed money must be repaid, both the principal amount borrowed as well as interest on the borrowed funds. These payments have contractual due dates. If payments are not prompt, creditors have powerful legal remedies, including forcing the company into bankruptcy. Consequently, when comparing two companies with the same return on equity, the one using less debt would generally be viewed as a safer (less risky) investment.

 

 

MINI EXERCISES

 

 

M1-19 (10 minutes)

 

($ millions)

Assets                =               Liabilities                 +              Equity

   $27,561                                    $23,826                                     $3,735

 

Dell receives more of its financing from nonowners ($23,826 million) than from owners ($3,735 million). Its owner financing comprises 13.6% of its total financing ($3,735 million/ $27,561 million).

 

 

 

 

M1-20 (10 minutes)

 

($ millions)

Assets                =               Liabilities                 +              Equity

     $8,652                                       $5,230                                     $3,422

 

Best Buy receives more of its financing from nonowners ($5,230 million) than from owners ($3,422 million).  Its owner financing comprises 40% of its total financing ($3,422 million/ $8,652 million).

 

 

M1-21 (15 minutes)

 

($ millions)	Assets	=	Liabilities	+	Equity
Hewlett-Packard	$113,331		$74,389		(a)  $38,942
General Mills	$19,110		(b)  $13,815		$5,295
Target	(c) $47,041		$33,461		$13,580

 

The percent of owner financing for each company follows:

Hewlett-Packard………………..    34.4%      ($38,942 million / $113,331 million)

General Mills…………………….    27.7%      ($5,295 million / $19,110 million)

Target………………………………    28.8%      ($13,580 million / $47,041 million)

 

Hewlett-Packard is more owner financed, while General Mills is more nonowner financed. High tech companies, such as HP, face more uncertain cash flows than do consumer product companies, such as General Mills and Target. Because nonowner financing is riskier, companies like HP (that face greater uncertainty) tend to utilize more equity in their capital structure.  

 

 

 

M1-22^A (15 minutes)

 

 

In its September 2008 annual report, Starbucks reports the following figures (in $ millions):

 

Assets	=	Liabilities	+	Equity
$ 5,672.6	=	$ 3,181.7	+	$ 2,490.9

 

As shown, the accounting equation holds for Starbucks. Also, we can see that Starbucks’ nonowner financing is 56.1% ($3,181.7 / $5,672.6) of its total financing.

 

M1-23^A (20 minutes)

 

DuPont Statement of Reinvested Earnings For Year Ended December 31, 2007
Beginning reinvested earnings, December 31, 2006………………	$ 9,679
Net income for 2007……………………………………………………………	2,988
Common stock dividends…………………………………………………..	(1,399)
Preferred stock dividends…………………………………………………..	(10)
Treasury stock retirement*………………………………………………….	(1,429)
Adjustment to apply new standard related to income taxes…..	116
Ending reinvested earnings, December 31, 2007…………………..	$ 9,945

 

*  Treasury Stock represents the company’s repurchase of Common Stock. The effect is to decrease stockholders’ equity, which is the opposite effect from the issuance of stock. During 2007, DuPont retired Treasury Stock and will not reissue these shares again. This transaction reduced the company’s retained earnings but did not affect net income for the year.

 

 

 

 

M1-24 (20 minutes)

 

1. BS and SCF d.  BS                           g.  SCF and SE
2. IS e.  SCF                         h.  SCF and SE
3. BS f.   BS and SE               i.   IS, SE, and SCF

 

M1-25 (10 minutes)

 

There are many stakeholders impacted by this business decision, including the following (along with a description of how):

 

• You as a Manager—your reputation, self-esteem, and potentially your livelihood could be negatively impacted.
• Creditors and Bondholders—credit decisions based on inaccurate information could occur.
• Shareholders—buying or selling shares based on inaccurate information could occur.
• Management and other Employees of your company—repercussions of your decision extend to all other employees. Also, a decision to record these revenues suggests an environment condoning dishonesty.

 

Indeed, your decisions can affect many more parties than you might initially realize. The short-term benefit of meeting Wall Street’s expectations could have serious long-term ramifications.

 

 

 

M1-26^B (10 minutes)

 

Internal controls are designed for the following purposes:

 

• Monitoring an organization’s activities to promote efficiency and to prevent wrongful use of its resources
• Ensuring the validity and credibility of external accounting reports
• Promoting effective operations
• Ensuring reliable internal reporting

 

Congress has a special interest in internal controls and reports about them.  Specifically, the absence or failure of internal controls can adversely affect the effectiveness of domestic and global financial markets. Enron provided Congress with a case in point.

 

 

EXERCISES

 

E1-27 (15 minutes)

 

         

1. Target has a proprietary credit card (the Target Card). Customers’ unpaid credit card balances at the end of the reporting period are similar to accounts receivable.

 

1. Target’s inventories consist of the product lines it carries: clothing, electronics, home furnishings, food products, and so forth.

 

1. Target’s PPE assets consist of land, buildings, interior improvements such as lighting, flooring, HVAC, store shelving, shopping carriages, and cash registers.

 

1. Although Target sells some of its merchandise via its Website, the majority of its sales activity is conducted in its retail locations. These stores represent a substantial and necessary capital investment for its business model.

 

E1-28 (20 minutes)

 

($ millions)

1. Using the accounting equation:

       Assets ($50,715)                        =  Liabilities ($11,627) + Equity (?)

          Thus:          $39,088                 =  Equity

 

High tech companies must contend with a substantial amount of risk relating to changing technology.  Future cash flows are, therefore, not as certain and cannot support high levels of debt. Thus, the company uses equity financing;  77.1% in the case of Intel.

 

 

1. Using the accounting equation at the beginning of the year:

Assets ($5,598)                          =  Liabilities (?) + Equity ($1,036)

          Thus: Beginning Liabilities     =  $4,562

       Using the accounting equation at the end of the year:

       Assets ($5,598 + $486)               =  Liabilities ($4,562 + $241) + Equity (?)

          Thus: Ending Equity               =  $1,281

 

Alternative approach to solving part (b):

DAssets($486) = DLiabilities($241) + DEquity(?)

         where “D” refers to “change in.”

            Thus: D Ending Equity = $486 – $241 = $245 and

            Ending equity = $1,036 + $245 = $1,281

 

 

 

1. Retained Earnings is the balance sheet account that provides the link between the balance sheet and the income statement. Each accounting period, Retained Earnings is updated by the net income (loss) reported for that period (and is reduced by any dividends that are paid to shareholders). The balance sheet and the income statement are, therefore, linked by this balance sheet account.

 

E1-29 (15 minutes)

 

External constituents use accounting information from financial statements to answer questions such as the following:

 

1. Shareholders (investors), ask questions such as:
2. Are the company’s resources adequate to carry out strategic plans?
3. Are the debts owed appropriate in amount given the company’s existing assets and plans for growth?
4. What is the current level of income (and its components)?
5. Is the current stock price appropriate given the company’s profitability and level of debt?

 

2. Creditors, ask questions such as:
3. Does the business have the ability to repay its debts as they come due?
4. Can the business take on additional debt?
5. Are current assets sufficient to cover current liabilities?

 

3. Employees, ask questions such as:
4. Is the business financially stable?
5. Can the business afford to pay higher salaries?
6. What are growth prospects for the organization?
7. Will the company be able to pay my pension when I retire?

 

E1-30 (10 minutes)

 

Computation of dividends

Beginning retained earnings, 2007……………………………………..	$  9,643.7
+  Net income……………………………………………………………………….	1,737.4
–  Cash dividends…………………………………………………………………	(?)
=  Ending retained earnings, 2007………………………………………….	$10,627.5

 

Thus, dividends were $753.6 million for 2007. The company paid out dividends equal to 43.4% of 2007 net income ($753.6 / $1,737.4).

 

 

 

E1-31 (20 minutes)

 

1. Colgate Palmolive was profitable during 2007 as witnessed by its positive net profit margin of 13%. As well, the profit margin is higher than in 2006, which is another good sign.

 

1. Colgate Palmolive’s asset turnover increased slightly from 1.39 in 2006 to 1.43 in 2007. This is a positive development as it indicates that operating assets are generating a higher level of sales than in the prior year.

 

1. ROA = Profit margin ´ asset turnover. 2007 ROA = 13% ´43 = 18.6%. 2006 ROA = 11% ´ 1.39 = 15.3%. Most of the increase in ROA during 2007 is driven by the increase in profitability from 11% to 13%.

 

 

 

E1-32 (15 minutes)

 

Return on assets  (ROA)	=	Net income / Average assets
	=	$715 / ($4,822 + $5,600)/2]
	=	13.7%

 

E1-33 (20 minutes)

 

1. Creditors are an important group of external stakeholders. They are primarily interested in the ability of the company to generate sufficient cash flow in order to repay the amounts owed. Stockholders are another significant stakeholder in the company. They are primarily interested in the company’s ability to effectively raise capital and to invest that capital in projects with a rate of return in excess of the cost of the capital raised, that is, to increase the value of the firm. Regulators such as the SEC and the tax authorities, including the IRS and state and local tax officials, are important constituents that are interested in knowing whether the company is complying with all applicable laws and regulations.

 

1. Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) are the various methods, rules, practices, and other procedures that have evolved over time in response to the need to regulate the preparation of financial statements. They are primarily set by the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB), a private sector entity with representatives from companies that issue financial statements, accounting firms that audit those statements, and users of financial information. Other bodies that contribute to GAAP are the AICPA, the EITF, and the SEC.

 

1. Financial information provides users with information that is useful in assessing the financial performance of companies and, therefore, in setting stock and bond prices. To the extent that these prices are accurate, the costs of the funds that companies raise will accurately reflect their relative efficiency and risk of operations. Companies that can utilize capital more effectively will be able to obtain that capital at a reasonable cost and society’s financial resources will be effectively allocated.

 

1. First, the preparation of financial statements involves an understanding of complex accounting rules and significant assumptions and considerable estimation. Second, GAAP allows for differing accounting treatments for the same transaction. And third, auditors are at a relative information disadvantage vis-à-vis company accountants. As the capital markets place increasing pressures on companies to perform, accountants are often placed in a difficult ethical position to use the flexibility given to them under GAAP in order to bias the financial results or to use their inside information to their advantage.

 

E1-34 (20 minutes)

 

1. ROE = Net income / Average stockholders’ equity

              = $315.5 million / [($2,490.9 million + $2,284.1 million)/2] = 13.2%

 

1. The repurchase of common stock reduces the denominator (average stockholders’ equity). The outflow of cash for the repurchase, however, reduces net income by the return on the cash that is forgone. Generally, the reduction in the denominator is greater than that for the numerator, and consequently ROE increases. That is one of the reasons cited for share repurchases.

 

1. Companies usually repurchase their own stock when they feel that it is undervalued by the market. The repurchase is a way to send a signal to the market to that effect. Company management is, in essence, backing up its assertions that the stock is undervalued with a tangible investment of the company’s funds. Companies also repurchase their own stock to have shares available to give to executives and other employees as compensation.

 

 

PROBLEMS

 

P1-35 (40 minutes)

 

     2006 ROE = $ 9,492 / [($28,506+ $33,098)/2] = 30.8%

     2007 ROE = $10,418 / [($28,470+$28,506)/2] = 36.6%

 

IBM’s ROE has increased from 2006 to 2007, and is well above the median ROE of 19% for other companies in the Dow Jones average.

 

     2006 ROA = $ 9,492 / [($103,234+ $105,748)/2] = 9.1%

     2007 ROA = $10,418 / [($120,431+$103,234)/2] = 9.3%

 

IBM’s ROA increased from 2006 to 2007, which is slightly above the median for other Dow Jones companies (on average) for 2007.

 

 

1. IBM sells products and services with a high level of technology and specialization. Companies that are able to achieve a competitive advantage with unique products and services typically enjoy above-level profitability and returns on equity.  Further, to the extent that the company is able to develop customer-specific products and services, competitive threats lessen and, thus, further increase its profitability. 

 

P1-36 (30 minutes)

a.

General Mills, Inc.

Income Statement ($ millions)

For Year Ended May 25, 2008

Revenue………………………………………………………………….    $13,652.1

Cost of goods sold…………………………………………………..        8,778.3

Gross profit…………………………………………………………….        4,873.8

Total expenses………………………………………………………..       3,579.1

Net income……………………………………………………………..     $ 1,294.7

 

 

 

General Mills, Inc.

Balance Sheet ($ millions)

May 25, 2008

Cash………………………	$     661.0	Total liabilities……………..	$12,825.8
Noncash assets………	18,380.6	Stockholders’ equity…….	6,215.8
Total assets…………….	$19,041.6	Total liabilities and equity	$19,041.6

 

 

 

General Mills, Inc.

Statement of Cash Flows ($ millions)

For Year Ended May 25, 2008

Cash from operating activities…………………………………       $ 1,729.9

Cash from investing activities…………………………………            (442.4)

Cash from financing activities…………………………………         (1,043.6)

Net change in cash…………………………………………………              243.9

Cash, beginning year………………………………………………              417.1

Cash, ending year…………………………………………………..       $     661.0

 

P1-36 (concluded)

 

1. A negative amount for cash from investing activities reflects further investment by the company in its long-term assets, which is generally a positive sign of management’s commitment to future business success. A negative amount for cash from financing activities reflects the reduction of long-term debt, which is often a positive sign of the company’s ability to retire debt obligations.

 

1. Profit margin =

 

 

Turnover of total assets =

 

 

Return on assets=

 

 

Return on equity =

 

 

P1-37 (30 minutes)

a.

Abercrombie & Fitch

Income Statement ($ millions)

For Year Ended February 2, 2008

Sales……………………………………………………………………..      $3,749.8

Cost of goods sold…………………………………………………        1,238.5

Gross profit……………………………………………………………        2,511.3

Expenses………………………………………………………………        2,035.6

Net income…………………………………………………………….      $   475.7

 

 

 

Abercrombie & Fitch

Balance Sheet ($ millions)

February 2, 2008

Cash………………………..	$   118.0	Total liabilities………………..	$   949.3
Noncash assets………..	2,449.6	Stockholders’ equity……….	1,618.3
Total assets……………..	$2,567.6	Total liabilities and equity..	$2,567.6

 

 

 

Abercrombie & Fitch

Statement of Cash Flows ($ millions)

For Year Ended February 2, 2008

Cash from operating activities…………………………………       $    817.8

Cash from investing activities…………………………………            (500.2)

Cash from financing activities…………………………………            (281.6)

Net change in cash…………………………………………………               36.0

Cash, beginning year………………………………………………               82.0

Cash, ending year…………………………………………………..       $    118.0

 

P1-37 (concluded)

 

1. A negative amount for cash from investing activities reflects further investment by the company in its long-term assets, which is generally a positive sign of management commitment to future business success. A negative amount for cash from financing activities reflects the reduction of long-term debt, which is often a positive sign of the company’s ability to retire debt obligations.

 

 

Profit margin =

 

 

Turnover of total assets =

 

 

Return on assets=

 

 

Return on equity =

 

 

P1-38 (30 minutes)

a.

Cisco Systems, Inc.

Income Statement ($ millions)

For Year Ended July 30, 2008

Sales……………………………………………………………………..       $39,540

Cost of goods sold…………………………………………………         14,056

Gross profit……………………………………………………………         25,484

Expenses………………………………………………………………         17,432

Net income…………………………………………………………….       $  8,052

 

 

 

Cisco Systems, Inc.

Balance Sheet ($ millions)

July 30, 2008

Cash………………………..	$  5,191	Total liabilities……………………	$24,332
Noncash assets………..	53,543	Stockholders’ equity…………..	34,402
Total assets………………	$58,734	Total liabilities and equity…..	$58,734

 

 

 

Cisco Systems, Inc.

Statement of Cash Flows ($ millions)

For Year Ended July 30, 2008

Cash from operating activities…………………………………       $12,089

Cash used in investing activities……………………………..          (4,193)

Cash used in financing activities……………………………..          (6,433)

Net change in cash…………………………………………………           1,463

Cash, beginning year………………………………………………           3,728

Cash, ending year…………………………………………………..       $  5,191

 

P1-38 (concluded)

 

1. A negative amount for cash from investing activities reflects further investment by the company in its long-term assets, which is generally a positive sign of management commitment to future business success. A negative amount for cash from financing activities reflects the reduction of long-term debt, which is often a positive sign of the company’s ability to retire debt obligations.

 

 

Profit margin =

 

 

Turnover of total assets =

 

 

Return on assets=

 

 

Return on equity =

 

 

P1-39 (15 minutes)

 

Crocker Corporation Statement of Stockholders’ Equity For Year Ended December 31, 2009
	Common Stock	Retained Earnings	Stockholders’ Equity
December 31, 2008……………………..	$  70,000	$ 30,000	$100,000
Issuance of common stock…………	30,000		30,000
Net income………………………………..		50,000	50,000
Cash dividends………………………….	_______	(25,000)	(25,000)
December 31, 2009……………………..	$100,000	$ 55,000	$155,000

 

 

 

 

 

P1-40 (15 minutes)

 

EA Systems, Inc. Statement of Stockholders’ Equity For Year Ended December 31, 2009
	Common Stock	Retained Earnings	Stockholders’ Equity
December 31, 2008……………………..	$ 550	$2,437	$2,987
Net income………………………………..		859	859
Cash dividends………………………….	____	(281)	(281)
December 31, 2009……………………..	$ 550	$3,015	$3,565

 

 

P1-41 (30 minutes)

 

1. ($ millions)

 

	Profit Margin (PM)	Asset Turnover (AT)	ROA (PM×AT)	ROE
2004	11.9% ($1,800.2/$15,083.2)	0.89 $15,083.2/[($16,779.9+$17,018.0)/2]	10.7%*	26.9% $1,800.2/[($6,629.5+$6,766.3)/2]
2005	9.9% ($1,568.3/$15,902.6)	0.95 $15,902.6/[($16,303.2+$17,018.0)/2]	9.4%	25.7% $1,568.3/[($5,558.2+$6,629.5)/2]
2006	9.0% ($1,499.5/$16,746.9)	1.00 $16,746.9/[($17,067.0+$16,303.2)/2]	9.0%	25.7% $1,499.5/[($6,097.4+$5,558.2)/2]
2007	10.0% ($1,822.9/$18,266.0)	1.03 $18,266.0/[($18,439.7+$17,067.0)/2]	10.3%	32.2% $1,822.9/[($5,223.7+$6,097.4)/2]

 

*rounding difference

 

Kimberly-Clark’s ROA improved over the 2005-2007 period, but its 2007 ROA is slightly lower than the ROA reported in 2004.  The improvement is the result of both improved profitability and asset turnover in recent years.

 

 

1. The repurchase of common stock reduces both the numerator (net income) and denominator (stockholders’ equity) of the return on equity calculation. Repurchases reduce net income by the forgone profit on the cash that is distributed to shareholders.  The repurchase of common stock reduces stockholders’ equity by $5 billion, thus decreasing the denominator by that amount. Generally, the denominator effect dominates: its reduction is greater than the reduction of the numerator.  Therefore, it is reasonable to predict that the repurchase would increase ROE.

 

P1-42 (30 minutes)

 

 

	Profit Margin (PM)	Asset Turnover (AT)	ROA (PM×AT)	ROE
2005	12.2% ($6,923/$56,741)	0.96 $56,741 / [($61,527+$57,048)/2]	11.7%	38.7% $6,923/[($18,475+$17,278)/2]
2006	12.7% ($8,684/$68,222)	0.69 $68,222/[($135,695+$61,527)/2]	8.8%	21.3% $8,684/[($62,908+$18,475)/2]
2007	13.5% ($10,340/$76,476)	0.56 $76,476/[($138,014+$135,695)/2]	7.6%	15.9% $10,340/[($66,760+$62,908)/2]
2008	14.5% ($12,075/$83,503)	0.59 $83,503/[($143,992+$138,014)/2]	8.6%	17.7% $12,075/[($69,494+$66,760)/2]

 

 

ROA and ROE declined markedly following the Gillette acquisition in fiscal 2006.  The assets of Gillette are included in the PG balance sheet from the date of this acquisition.  The year prior to this acquisition, however, does not contain these assets.  The decrease in ROA is driven primarily by the decrease in asset turnover as profit margin remained flat in the year following the acquisition.  Likewise, PG’s stockholders’ equity increased markedly as a result of the stock issued in the acquisition.  This issuance reduced ROE as the increase in equity more than offset the increase in net income.

 

 

2006. The acquisition of Gillette dramatically affected both ROA and ROE. Since the assets of Gillette are included in PG’s balance sheet (beginning on the date of acquisition), the PG assets increased markedly in fiscal 2006.  Likewise, stockholders’ equity increased substantially in fiscal 2006 as PG issued additional shares to acquire Gillette.  The resulting increase in stockholders’ equity markedly reduced ROE in that year, although ROE remains about twice as high as the ROE for other publicly-traded companies.

 

P1-42—concluded

 

1. The repurchase of common stock reduces both the numerator (net income) and denominator (stockholders’ equity) of the return on equity calculation. Repurchases reduce net income by the forgone profit on the cash that is distributed to shareholders.  The repurchase of common stock reduces stockholders’ equity by $32 billion, thus decreasing the denominator by that amount. Generally, the denominator effect dominates: its reduction is greater than the reduction of the numerator.  Therefore, it is reasonable to predict that the repurchase would increase ROE.

 

 

 

 

P1-43 (20 minutes)

 

1. Return on equity is net income divided by the average total stockholders’ equity.

Nokia’s ROE:  €7,205 / [(€17,338 + €12,060)/2] = 49.0%.

 

1. We know that sales minus expenses equals net income. Using Nokia’s numbers we obtain:

  €51,058 – Expenses = €7,205 à Expenses = €43,853.

 

1. Companies repurchase their own stock for a number of reasons. First, managers may believe that the company’s stock is undervalued by the market. The repurchase is a way to signal the market to that effect. Essentially, company management is backing up its assertions that the stock is undervalued with a tangible investment of the company’s funds. Second, firms often use treasury shares to honor executive and other employees’ stock option exercises. Third, stock buybacks return cash to investors who may prefer capital gains (from a buyback) to ordinary dividends, for tax reasons.

 

P1-44 (20 minutes)

 

1. ROA = Net income / Average assets

 

TJX 2008 ROA = $772 / [($6,600 + $6,086) / 2] = 12.2%

 

ANF 2008 ROA = $476 / [($2,568 + $2,248) /2] = 19.8%

 

 

	TJX	ANF
Profit Margin	$772/$18,647 = 4.1%	$476/$3,750 = 12.7%
Asset Turnover	$18,647/[($6,600+$6,086)/2] = 2.94	$3,750/[($2,568+$2,248)/2 = 1.56
ROA	4.1% × 2.94 = 12.2%*	12.7% × 1.56 = 19.8%

 

* Rounding difference

 

12. ANF is an upscale clothing retailer and, thus, premium prices its clothing. This is evident in ANF’s higher profit margin (12.7% compared to 4.1% at TJX). TJX’s value-pricing business model relies on higher turnover of clothing with lower margins. Although its turnover rate is nearly twice as high as ANF’s, it is not high enough to compensate for its markedly lower net operating profit margin. ANF is performing well on both measures and its return on assets is 62% higher than that of TJX.

 

 

P1-45 (30 minutes)

 

a.

	2006	2007
ROA	$3,544/[($29,989+$28,975)/2] = 12.1%	$2,395/[($28,975+$29,392)/2] = 8.2%
Profit Margin	$3,544/$20,895 = 17.0%	$2,395/$22,787 = 10.5%
Asset Turnover	$20,895/[($29,989+$28,975)/2] = 0.71	$22,787/[($28,975+$29,392)/2] = 0.78

 

 

     

1. McDonald’s ROA decreased from 2006 to 2007, primarily due to a decrease in profitability as its asset turnover has only slightly increased during this period.

 

P1-46 (30 minutes)

 

a.

	Profit margin	Asset Turnover	ROA
2004	$2,841/$20,011 = 14.2%	$20,011/[($20,708+$17,600)/2] = 1.04	14.9% ´ 1.04 = 14.8%
2005	$3,111/$21,167 = 14.7%	$21,167/[($20,541+$20,708)/2] = 1.03	14.7% ´ 1.03 = 15.1%
2006	$3,851/$22,923 = 16.8%	$22,923/[($21,294+$20,541)/2] = 1.10	16.8% ´ 1.10 = 18.4%
2007	$4,096/$24,462 = 16.7%	$24,462/[($24,694+$21,294)/2] = 1.06	16.7% ´ 1.06 = 17.7%*

 

                * minor rounding difference

 

3M’s ROA increased markedly from the 2004-2005 period to the 2006-2007 period.

 

 

1. Although both profit margin and turnover increased for the company, profit margin is the primary factor driving the improvement in its ROA across this time period.

 

P1-47^A (25 minutes)

1. The auditors address their report to the company’s board of directors and the shareholders of Apple, Inc. This is an important point. Auditors work for the benefit of the shareholders and report directly to the board of directors, the elected representatives of the shareholders whose job it is to protect shareholder interests. It would not be appropriate for the external auditors to report directly to management because the auditors are examining management’s activities as described in the company’s financial statements. Reporting to the board preserves the auditor’s independence.
2. The audit process consists of two components. First the auditors assess the company’s system of internal controls to ensure the information in the financial statements was gathered, recorded, aggregated in accordance with GAAP. This involves an assessment of the company’s accounting policies together with the assumptions used and estimates made in the preparation of the financial statements. Second, the auditors examine, on a test basis, evidence supporting the amounts and disclosures in the statements. The key word is test. Auditors do not examine each transaction. They take a sample from the transactions. If that sample does not uncover any irregularities, they go no further. If it does, they expand the sample until they are confident that the amounts presented in the statements fairly present the company’s performance and condition in accordance with GAAP.
3. The nature of the independent auditors’ opinion is that the financial statements “present fairly, in all material respects, the financial condition of the company.” Because this is standard audit-report language, any deviations should raise a flag. “Present fairly” does not mean absolute assurance that the financials are error-free. It means that a reasonable person would conclude that the financial statements reasonably describe the financial condition of the company.
4. KPMG also rendered an opinion on the company’s system of internal controls as required by sections 302 and 404 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act. Internal controls are designed to insure the integrity of the financial reporting system and the preservation of the company’s assets. A well-functioning internal control system is a critical component of the company’s overall corporate governance system.

 

P1-48 (20 minutes)

 

1. Steve Jobs made assertions that the Sarbanes-Oxley Act requires all CEOs and CFOs to make. In particular, Jobs certified that:
   • He has read the financial reports.
   • The financial reports do not contain any significant (material) misstatement or omit to state a significant fact that should have been included. The financial reports are, therefore, complete.
   • The financial reports fairly present the financial condition of the company.
   • The company maintains a system of internal controls and those controls are functioning correctly.

 

1. Congress passed the Sarbanes-Oxley Act following a spate of corporate accounting scandals in the early 2000s. The impetus for the legislation was the belief that some CEOs and CFOs no longer assumed responsibility for the financial reporting of their companies. By requiring these high-ranking executives to personally certify to the items referenced in part a above, Congress wanted to encourage closer scrutiny of the financial reporting process at the highest levels of the company.

 

1. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act prescribes significant penalties for falsely certifying to the completeness and correctness of the financial reports. CEOs and CFOs face fines of up to $5 million and prison terms of up to 20 years. Additionally, should the company later restate its financial statements as a result of wrongful false reporting, the CEOs and CFOs may be required to forfeit any profits earned as a result of that reporting. This forfeiture has been labeled “disgorgement” in the financial press.

 

P1-49 (30 minutes)

 

Following is the statement of Corporate Governance from GE’s Website as of early 2009:

 

1. Role of Board and Management

    GE’s business is conducted by its employees, managers and officers, under the direction of the chief executive officer (CEO) and the oversight of the board, to enhance the long-term value of the Company for its shareowners. The board of directors is elected by the shareowners to oversee management and to assure that the long-term interests of the shareowners are being served. Both the board of directors and management recognize that the long-term interests of shareowners are advanced by responsibly addressing the concerns of other stakeholders and interested parties including employees, recruits, customers, suppliers, GE communities, government officials and the public at large.

 

2. Functions of Board

    The board of directors has eight scheduled meetings a year at which it reviews and discusses the performance of the Company, its plans and prospects, as well as immediate issues facing the Company. Directors are expected to attend all scheduled board and committee meetings. In addition to its general oversight of management, the board also performs a number of specific functions, including:

1. selecting, evaluating and compensating the CEO and overseeing CEO succession planning;
2. providing counsel and oversight on the selection, evaluation, development and compensation of senior management;
3. reviewing, monitoring and, where appropriate, approving fundamental financial and business strategies and major corporate actions;
4. assessing major risks facing the Company — and reviewing options for their mitigation; and
5. ensuring processes are in place for maintaining the integrity of the Company – the integrity of the financial statements, the integrity of compliance with law and ethics, the integrity of relationships with customers and suppliers, and the integrity of relationships with other stakeholders.

 

3. Qualifications

    Directors should possess the highest personal and professional ethics, integrity and values, and be committed to representing the long-term interests of the shareowners. They must also have an inquisitive and objective perspective, practical wisdom and mature judgment. We endeavor to have a board representing diverse experience at policy-making levels in business, government, education and technology, and in areas that are relevant to the Company’s global activities.

        Directors must be willing to devote sufficient time to carrying out their duties and responsibilities effectively, and should be committed to serve on the board for an extended period of time. Directors should offer their resignation in the event of any significant change in their personal circumstances, including a change in their principal job responsibilities.

        Directors who also serve as CEOs of publicly-traded companies or in equivalent positions should not serve on more than two boards of public companies in addition to the GE board, and other directors should not serve on more than four other boards of public companies in addition to the GE board. Current positions in excess of these limits may be maintained unless the board determines that doing so would impair the director’s service on the GE board.

        The board does not believe that arbitrary term limits on directors’ service are appropriate, nor does it believe that directors should expect to be renominated annually until they reach the mandatory retirement age. The board self-evaluation process described below will be an important determinant for board tenure. Directors will not be nominated for election to the board after their 73rd birthday, although the full board may nominate candidates over 73 in special circumstances.

 

4. Independence of Directors

    A majority of the directors will be independent directors, as independence is determined by the board, based on the guidelines set forth below.

        All future non-employee directors will be independent. GE seeks to have a minimum of ten independent directors at all times, as independence is determined by the board based on the guidelines set forth below, and it is the board’s goal that at least two-thirds of the directors will be independent. Directors who do not satisfy GE’s independence guidelines also make valuable contributions to the board and to the Company by reason of their experience and wisdom.

        For a director to be considered independent, the board must determine that the director does not have any direct or indirect material relationship with GE. The board has established guidelines to assist it in determining director independence, which conform to or are more exacting than the independence requirements in the New York Stock Exchange listing requirements (NYSE rules). In addition to applying these guidelines, the board will consider all relevant facts and circumstances in making an independence determination.

        The board will make and publicly disclose its independence determination for each director when the director is first elected to the board and annually thereafter for all nominees for election as directors. If the board determines that a director who satisfies the NYSE rules is independent even though he or she does not satisfy all of GE’s independence guidelines, this determination will be disclosed and explained in the next proxy statement.

        In accordance with NYSE rules, independence determinations under the guidelines in section (a) below will be based upon a director’s relationships with GE during the 36 months preceding the determination. Similarly, independence determinations under the guidelines in section (b) below will be based upon the extent of commercial relationships during the three completed fiscal years preceding the determination.

 

1. The cornerstone of GE’s governance structure is its reliance on an independent and qualified Board of Directors. Independence means that insiders are not involved in oversight of the company’s managers. This helps avoid potential conflicts of interest.  “Highly qualified” directors ensure that those responsible for oversight have the knowledge to perform their duties and the conviction to ask probing questions.

 

1. Governance structures serve shareholders (and indirectly, public interest). The shareholders of GE hope to ensure that the company’s policies are adhered to and that the interests of shareholders are given paramount consideration in the management of the business.

 

 

DISCUSSION POINTS

 

D1-50 (30 minutes)

 

Financing can come from a number of sources, including operating creditors, borrowed funds, and the sale of stock. Each has its strengths and weaknesses.

 

1. Operating creditors – operating creditors are merchandise and service suppliers, including employees. Generally, these liabilities are non-interest bearing. As a result, companies typically use this source of credit to the fullest extent possible, often stretching payment times. However, abuse of operating creditors has a significant downside. The company may be unable to supply its operating needs and the damage to employee morale might have significant repercussions. Operating credit must, therefore, be used with care.

 

2. Borrowed funds – borrowed money typically carries an interest rate. Because interest expense is deductible for tax purposes, borrowed funds reduce income tax expense. The taxes saved are called the “tax shield.” The deductibility of interest reduces the effective cost of borrowing. The downside of debt is that the company must make principal and interest payments as scheduled. Failure to make payments on time can result in severe consequences – creditors have significant legal remedies, including forcing the company into bankruptcy and requiring its liquidation. The lower cost of debt must be balanced against the fixed payment obligations.

 

3. Sale of stock – companies can sell various classes of stock to investors. Some classes of stock have mandatory dividend payments. On other classes of stock, dividends are not a legal requirement until declared by the board of directors. Consequently, unlike debt payments, some dividends can be curtailed in business downturns. The downside of stock issuance is its cost. Because equity is the most expensive source of capital, companies use it sparingly.

 

D1-51 (30 minutes)

 

Each of the three primary financial statements provides a different perspective on the company’s financial performance and condition.

 

1. Income statement. The income statement provides information on the company’s sales, expenses, and net income or loss. Profitability indicates that the company’s goods or services are valued by the market, that is, customers are willing to pay a price that is sufficient to cover the costs of providing those goods and/or services together with an adequate return on invested capital. Further, the income statement is prepared on an accrual basis, where revenues are recognized when “earned” and expenses when “incurred.” Accountants do not wait for cash to be received or paid to record revenues and expenses. Consequently, management is able to communicate some of its private information about expected cash inflows or outflows through its recording of revenues and expenses. Presumably this information is valuable to financial statement readers because the income statement provides information about the economic profit of the company.

 

2. Balance sheet. The balance sheet reports the resources available to the company and how the company obtained those resources (the sources). The balance sheet also reveals asset categories (providing insight into management’s investment philosophy) and the manner in which management has financed its operations (the relative use of debt versus equity). Efficient management of the balance sheet is critical to financial performance and careful analysis of the balance sheet can provide clues into the effectiveness of the company’s management team and the viability of the company within the context of its industry.

 

3. Statement of cash flows. Cash is important to a company’s continued operations. Debts must be paid in cash and employees typically only accept cash in payment of their services. Companies must generate positive cash flow over the long run in order to survive. The income statement, prepared on an accrual basis, does not directly provide information about cash flows. But the statement of cash flows does, and, for that reason, it is a critical financial statement. The statement of cash flows tells us the sources of cash and how cash has been used. In particular, the statement reports operating, investing and financing cash flows. From the statement, we can infer whether the company’s sources of cash are long-term or transitory. This is important to forecasting future cash flows. In addition, the uses of cash provide insight into management’s investment philosophy that can be a valuable input into our evaluation of management and valuation of the company.

 

D1-52 (30 minutes)

 

Transparency is the degree to which the financial statements accurately and completely portray the financial condition of the company and the results of its operating activities. Transparent financial statements are timely and provide all the information required to effectively evaluate the financial performance of the company. Accuracy, timeliness, and completeness are important to financial statement readers who seek financial information that is relevant and reliable. Transparency became a central issue in financial reporting following the accounting scandals of the early 2000s, when analysts believed too many financial statements lacked transparency.  

 

Balancing companies’ desire to issue transparent financial statements is their need to protect proprietary information. Markets are very competitive, and the information disclosed to investors and creditors is also disclosed to the company’s competitors. Most critical is information relating to the company’s strategic direction. Even historical information, however, provides insight into the relative profitability of the company’s operating units that can be effectively utilized by future competitors.

 

There has traditionally been tension between companies and the financial professionals (especially investment analysts) who press firms for more and more financial and nonfinancial information.

 

D1-53 (30 minutes)

 

Accounting measures other than net income have become commonplace in corporate press releases. By their use, companies seek to redefine the benchmark the market uses to evaluate the companies’ performance. These non-GAAP income metrics often create a lower bar that companies can more easily reach. By touting non-GAAP performance measures, companies hope to improve the market’s assessment of performance.

 

The SEC will not accept non-GAAP financial statements for quarterly and annual financial reporting. In fact, auditors must cite GAAP exceptions in their audit opinion, which creates a significant red flag. Companies are allowed to use non-GAAP measures in press releases, provided that they also reconcile the non-GAAP numbers to GAAP numbers in the same press release.

 

It is a criminal offense to issue false or misleading financial statements for the purpose of influencing security prices. Also, most companies have developed and published to employees, codes of conduct that prohibit the falsification of financial reporting for the purpose of job retention, promotion, or compensation. Officially, senior management believes that false financial reports pose significant ethical issues that must be clearly communicated to all employees. Nonetheless, we continue to witness corporate executives doing a “perp walk” on national TV as they are escorted to jail by federal authorities.

 

Condoning exceptions to financial reporting implicitly condones theft in all of its forms, and the corporate culture quickly deteriorates. Proper corporate governance requires the communication of clear guidelines about what information may be communicated in press releases and how internal performance measures are to be constructed. These must be enforced to the letter.

 

Buffett is rightly concerned with the use of non-GAAP measures of performance. Once the door is opened to improper reporting, it becomes increasingly difficult to consistently measure performance.

 

D1-54^B (30 minutes)

 

The SEC has voiced its concern over the perceived lack of independence of auditors, and Congress has passed legislation to define the activities that auditors may and may not perform for their clients. The issue of independence first arose when auditors faced no controls. In response to declining audit fees, public accounting firms sought to bolster their income with management consulting engagements, such as software development, M&A assistance, internal audit outsourcing, supply chain management, and a host of other services.

 

As management consulting revenues and profits grew disproportionately compared to traditional audit revenues and profit, the SEC became concerned that auditors might be unduly influenced to issue biased audit reports rather than risk losing lucrative management consulting fees from the same client. In response, the SEC compelled public accounting firms to divest their management consulting subsidiaries. Further, firms were limited as the types of non-audit engagements they could perform for clients.

 

Auditors are an important component of the corporate governance system, and their effectiveness is lessened if their independence is compromised. The board of directors (specifically, the audit committee) must continually evaluate the independence of the company’s auditors.